We can be devastated by the suffering of someone we love and almost unmoved when someone we condemn is hurting.
The suffering is no less real. Our concern is simply not the same.
Sometimes we even mistake that distance for moral clarity.
We read about another family’s grief and move on. Someone close to us grows quiet, and we fail to notice. When a person has hurt us, we may feel they no longer deserve our concern.
Not because we are cruel. There is more suffering in the world than any one of us can take in. But I wonder what happens when protecting ourselves becomes a habit of separating ourselves.
We know fear, loss, loneliness. We know how much it means when someone stays beside us in a difficult moment, without trying to fix everything. We know the simple wish to be happy and free from suffering.
That wish is not ours alone. Yet we draw invisible circles around the people whose well-being matters to us. Family and friends inside. Strangers, opponents, those who have hurt us, and those the world has forgotten beyond the edge.
In my meditation practice, I return to tonglen, an old Tibetan practice of taking and sending.
Breathing in, I imagine suffering as dark smoke. In the heart, it meets a diamond of clear awareness and is transformed. Breathing out, I offer compassion and the wish for relief.
I begin with my own suffering. Then someone I love. Someone I feel neutral toward. Someone I find difficult. Those who are unseen, alone, or forgotten. Finally, all sentient beings who suffer.
The wish remains the same, even for someone whose actions I cannot accept: May you be free from suffering.
No one has to earn that wish. It asks me to see a person as more than the one thing I find difficult about them.
Compassion does not erase responsibility. We can oppose cruelty, protect those at risk, and set firm boundaries. Wishing for someone to be free of the fear, hatred, or confusion that drives harmful behavior is not the same as excusing it.
And in the quiet of practice, something subtler can become apparent. Pain remains. It belongs to lives as different as our own. Yet before the mind sorts it into mine and yours, deserving and undeserving, there is simply suffering. The separation that makes indifference feel natural becomes less convincing.
The practice continues when we leave the cushion. In listening rather than dismissing. In noticing the person others overlook. In standing against harm without adding contempt to the world.
We cannot relieve every person’s suffering. But we can meet anyone with compassion, even those we oppose.
Imagine a world in which everyone was genuinely concerned about the well-being of others. We would still face loss, conflict, and difficult decisions. But far less suffering would be added through indifference, contempt, and cruelty.
Who have you left outside the circle of your compassion?